Mutah Fiqh FAQ

Question:

----- Original Message ----- 
From: Mutah Web Master 
Sent: Saturday, August 03, 2002 6:56 PM
Subject: More Mutah Questions
Salaam,

I have a few more questions:

1) Can a Shia marry a Sunni in Nikah?

2) Can A Shia marry a Sunni in Mutah, if the Sunni personally accepts the legitimacy of Mutah without becoming a Shia?

3) Can someone who is chaste marry someone in Mutah who has not been chaste, but after knowing about Mutah agrees to doing Mutah?

4) What is the cure to the widespread sexual immorality and haram relationships amongst the Muslim youth? 

5) Can someone who was having a haram western style boyfriend-girlfriend relationship convert that relationship into a halal Mutah relationship?

6) Can a Sayyida female marry a non-Sayyid Male in Nikah?

7) Can a Sayyida Female marry a non-Sayyid Male in Mutah?

8) Can a Shia do Mutah with a Christian or a Jew?

Thank you for your advice.

Salaam.

MM

 

 

From: Representatives Ayatullah Sayyid Ali Khamenei

Source: Wilayah.org

Answer:

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu.
The answer is as follows:

Bismihi Ta`ala
1 & 2) There is no objection in doing that, in itself.
3) It is mustahabb (recommended) that the woman whom one wants to contract mut`ah with her to be a chaste believer.
4) The solution for this problem is by making legal, Islamic relationships (marriage) and to try our best to avoid doing haram, illegal acts event through remembering death, Divine punishment and the Hell in addition to the very bad consequences of commission of such sins and those result form acting against the Divine orders.
5) Yes, with observation of Islamic requirements it is permissible. 
6) There is no objection in doing so.
7) There is no objection in doing so.
8) It is permissible for Shi'ite male to contract mut`ah with females of ahlul kitab (the People of the Book).

With prayers for your success,
wassalam.


From: M Razawi

Source: ic-el.org

Answer:

1) Can a Shia marry a Sunni in Nikah?

a - 1) Yes.

2) Can A Shia marry a Sunni in Mutah, if the Sunni personally accepts the legitimacy of Mutah without becoming a Shia?

a - 2) Yes.

3) Can someone who is chaste marry someone in Mutah who has not been chaste, but after knowing about Mutah agrees to doing Mutah?

a - 3) Yes.

4) What is the cure to the widespread sexual immorality and haram relationships amongst the muslim youth? 

a - 4) Islamic Long Period of Short Period Marriage

5) Can someone who was having a haram western style boyfriend-girlfriend relationship convert that relationship into a halal Mutah relationship?

a - 5) Yes.

6) Can a Sayyida female marry a non-Sayyid Male in Nikah?

a - 6) Yes.

7) Can a Sayyida Female marry a non-Sayyid Male in Mutah?

a - 7) Yes, with her father's permission.

8) Can a Shia do Mutah with a Christian or a Jew?

 

From: Representatives Of Ayatullah Sayyid Ali Seestani

Source: Rafed.net

Answer:

 

 

 

From: Ayatullah Fazel Lankarani

Source: lankarani.net

Answer:

From :
"fazel"

To :
<mutah1@hotmail.com>

Subject :
The aswer

Date :
Sun, 8 Sep 2002 21:46:42 +0430

In the name of the Exalted


Salamon alaykom


1 The marriage is of no problem, but to prevent some ideological and religious problems its recommended not to be done.


2 Yes, its of on matter.


3 Yes, its permissible.


4 Marriage, observing divine limits, and keeping away from muharramat (unlawful actions- bad deeds) would be the only cure.


5 based on ehtiyat-e wajib (mandatory precaution), the permission of the girls father for mutah is needed; they can do mutah if they will possibly be driven to haram, though.


6 Yes, its of no matter.


7 - Yes, its of no matter.


8 Yes, he can; but its period (length) should not be too long.


Wassalam

 

 

 

From: Ayatullah Tabrizi

Source: His response via email.

Answer:

From :
" " <tabrizi_t>

To :
mutah1@hotmail.com

Subject :


Date :
Thu, 28 Nov 2002 11:09:09 +0000

Attachment : 3252.gif (93k)